Find a Q&A post that you would like to critique. After opening the thread and thinking about the question and the answer, post your critique.
Remember that your goal here is not simply to agree or disagree with your peers’ answer to their question or to share some thoughts that the author’s post brings to mind from your own reading (although such peer comments may be part of your critique); what you should be attempting here is an analysis and evaluation of the entire Q&A discussion and any argumentation intended to defend the view they advance. Most students find it very challenging to critically evaluate either their own work as well as that of their peers.
Please note that your critique should be in the range of 200-400 words to be eligible for full credit.
My question is: What came first the “Chicken” or God?
“My answer to this question is: This argument will start with the end in mind- Conclusion: GOD exists… Clearly here, on earth that is, beautifully crafted things exist. Take for example an architectural masterpiece created by famous architects such as Mies van der Rohe, Le Corbusier and or Frank Lloyd Wright, their work is certainly stunning and amazing all together but nonetheless manmade… Chickens on the other hand are not manmade, not now and not ever. Gods existence however has always been and will always be. Drawing on the premise that “being” or “existence” has to be in order for both the chicken and God to exist however it is argued that simply God had to exist first in order to make the perfect chicken in its own design and purpose. We realize the purpose of the chicken is to sustain life, the life God created and designed from the beginning of time. In order to support life, existence of things like the chicken and other to sustain humans or all other things that God created. Putting the chicken before God is absurd knowing what we know about the chicken and its purpose and limitations to its very own existence as a chicken. Based on reason alone one can conclude that a God with such power as to create the heavens and earth absolutely needed to exist before the chicken so that the chicken could be created in the first place. Creation is widely argued but if you simply take the two examples here, chickens and buildings/homes, you can conclude human beings can build buildings and homes but don’t have a chance to create a living creature such as chicken, it must be God who created the chicken. “
