Assignment Prompt
Compose a comparative analysis that identifies similarities and/or difference between you and a person from I Am Malala. You may choose Malala Yousafzai or Ziauddin Yousafzai (Malala’s father).
For this essay, look closely at the example essays provided. You should compare and/or contrast multiple points. For example, if you choose Ziauddin, you may choose to discuss the similarities and differences between how you both raise your children, how you both believe in fighting for equality, and how you both have a special regard for your spouse. If you choose Malala, you may decide to write about the similarities and differences between how you both love your homeland, how you both have important relationships with parents who helped shape you, and how you both have difficult experiences you had to overcome.
Resist choosing Malala only if you are a woman or Ziauddin if you are a man. Select based on the one with which you would have the best points of comparison/contrast.
Assignment Criteria
This comparative analysis essay should be 550-650 words in length. It should be tightly organized. The essay should be in Times New Roman 12-point font and double-spaced. Format the document using MLA citation style; include in-text citations for quotes, paraphrases, and summaries; and cite the book I Am Malala on the Works Cited page.
Read an example comparative analysis student essay example comparative analysis student essay here.
Assignment Rubric
5- Excellent: A fully developed comparative analysis that distinctly identifies similarities and differences with a clear organizational structure. The position is fully supported with information from personal experience, the reading, and logical explanations. Correct quotes, paraphrases, and summaries are integrated seamlessly and include in-text citations. There are few if any errors in writing conventions and all assignment criteria are met.
4-Good: A developed comparative analysis that identifies similarities and differences with some organizational structure. The position is mostly supported with information from personal experience, the reading, and logical explanations. A noticeable attempt is made integrating at correct quotes, paraphrases, and summaries with in-text citations. There are some errors in writing conventions and all assignment criteria are met.
3-Adequate: A comparative analysis that identifies some similarities and differences, but they lack organization and clarity. The position is partially supported. There are a few attempts at quotes, paraphrases, and summaries with in-text citations. There are errors in writing conventions, but they do not hinder readability. Most assignment criteria are met.
2- Basic: Response without clear similarities and differences with little or no support. Few if any attempts at integrating sources or in-text citations. There are significant errors in writing conventions, and some hinder readability. Assignment criteria are not met.
1-Poor: Response with no position or support. There are significant errors in writing conventions that hinder readability, and/or the response is very short.
