Article Critique Outline: Instructions and Checklist
1. Article Summary (one paragraph)
A. Concise summary of the main research question and objectives
B. Summary of key findings and conclusions presented in the article
2. Evaluation of Methodology (one paragraph)
A. Discussion of the appropriateness of the research design for the
research question
B. Assessment of the sample size, selection criteria, and potential biases
C. Examination of data collection methods and measurement tools used
D. Consideration of any limitations in the methodology that could affect
the validity of the findings
3. Strengths of the Article (one paragraph)
A. Identification of novel insights or contributions to the field
B. Thoroughness of the literature review and integration of previous
research
C. Comprehensive discussion of implications and potential practical
applications
4. Weaknesses of the Article (one paragraph)
A. Addressing of potential confounding variables or alternative
explanations.
B. Inadequate discussion of limitations and potential biases
C. Gaps or inconsistencies in the presentation of the research findings
D. Potential conflicts of interest or sources of funding not adequately
disclosed.
5. Implications and Future Research (4-5 sentences)
A. Analysis of the broader implications of the study’s findings
B. Suggestions for future research directions and areas of further
investigation
C. Identification of potential policy or intervention implications based on
the findings.
6. Your Opinion on the Article (1-2 paragraphs)
A. Final assessment of the article’s overall contribution to the field
B. Personal reflections on the significance of the research and its relevance
to current debates, do you agree or disagree with the findings?
IMPORTANT INFORMATION:
By following this outline, you can provide a comprehensive critique of
the chosen article, examining its methodology, strengths, weaknesses,
ethical considerations, and potential implications for future research
and practice.
The paper should be about 2 pages long if you double space it.
I will grade the article critiques based on how well you understand the
article. It does NOT need to be in APA format. You can use any format
you like. I am looking at your critical thinking skills and
comprehension.
There is no word limit or restriction, just make sure you cover all the
points listed above.
You still must have proper grammar, syntax, and spelling. You must
write in an academic, scholarly tone.
