DISCUSSION 12
Tommy Teenager (TT) is an enthusiastic, new employee at a local grocery store, Food Fetch (FF). His boss is Mary Manager (MM). One day, while accepting a shipment of food from Dandy Distributor (DD), Mary tells the DD driver about TT. She exclaims in front of TT what a great job he is doing, and that she would not be surprised if he ended up running the place someday.
One very busy Saturday, before a blizzard is forecast to hit the area, TT is the backroom working when DD pulls up with a delivery. DD is in a hurry to get unloaded and get on the road to beat the weather, and DD remembers what MM told him when he sees TT; DD asks TT to sign for the shipment. TT does not have any idea what he is doing. Still, he realizes how rushed MM is and how FF is running low on groceries on this busy, snowy Saturday. TT just wants to help, and signs for the shipment. TT puts the invoice on MM’s desk but forgets to tell her about it.
Three months later, DD calls MM to ask when she is going to pay for the shipment. MM knew nothing about TT signing for it and did not see the invoice on her messy desk.
Explain why FF might be liable to pay. In all instances, be sure to distinguish liability for agents and principals. Additionally, does it matter whether MM knew TT did or did not have authority to act on behalf of FF?
DISCUSSION 13
Big Business (BB) employs Oscar Outspoken (OO). OO has worked in the warehouse at BB for years. He is not management, but due to his experience and political savvy, he has become a de facto leader of the warehouse workers.
BB has grown tired of OO’s complaints, and BB believes OO’s continued employment at BB will result in workers complaining like him. To stop further trouble, BB fires OO without giving a reason. OO sues BB for his firing.
You’re a lawyer representing BB. Using this week’s material, discuss the strengths and weaknesses of your client’s position on their dispute, and for your replies to other posts, respectfully defend your position against the other “lawyers” representing the opposite side.
