For this paper, you will identify a controversial topic and present both (two) sides of the controversy. You will state each side’s position in the terminology used in the textbook (i.e. claim, support, warrant) and find and discuss reasons why each side has difficulty convincing the other that they are wrong.
This final determination will require analyzing and comparing the elements of each side’s argument. For example, you may find that the two sides do not actually have the same understanding of the issue (warrant).
Merely explain and analyze the arguments for each side. As a conclusion, you may offer a compromise; this is the only part of the essay that may read like an opinion. The essay must display a clear understanding of the terminology used and the arguments used to defend positions.
Research is required; in-text citations and a works cited page must be included; six sources minimum. You may include a working bibliography page if your research extended past the sources you cited in the essay.