Begin by critiquing the key variables and operational definitions:
Discuss the independent, dependent, and/or other key study variables of the attached paper.
Describe the operational definitions of key variables (independent and dependent). To what extent are the operational definitions clearly presented by the authors?
Next, evaluate the reliability and validity of measures used for key variables:
To what extent are the measures expected to be consistent? How well do the authors cite evidence to demonstrate reliability?
To what extent are the measures expected to measure what is intended? How well do the authors cite evidence to demonstrate validity?
Finally, examine the target population and sampling methods:
What is the study’s target population, and how does this compare to the accessible population?
Describe the specific sampling method used (plus whether it is probability or nonprobability) and the inclusion/exclusion criteria.
Evaluate the strengths and limitations of the sampling method.
Describe the study participants and analyze the extent to which participants represent the target population.
Paper should be 3 pages with 5 current (<6 years) references.
